Basic Search  |  Summaries  |  Advanced Search

Top 5 Offense Groups (Groups Defined)	Penalty Total	Number of Records
environment-related offenses	$1,143,865,795	36
competition-related offenses	$233,860,000	2
consumer-protection-related offenses	$49,700,000	6
safety-related offenses	$36,150,550	24
employment-related offenses	$32,938,305	11

Top 5 Primary Offense Types	Penalty Total	Number of Records
environmental violation	$1,143,865,795	36
kickbacks and bribery	$230,000,000	1
consumer protection violation	$49,700,000	6
nuclear safety violation	$33,560,000	3
labor relations violation	$28,029,760	6

Notes: Parent-subsidiary linkages are based on relationships current as of the latest revision listed in the Update Log, which may vary from what was the case when a violation occurred. The penalty totals are adjusted to account for the fact that the individual entries below may include both agency records and settlement announcements for the same case; or else a penalty covering multiple locations may be listed in the individual records for each of the facilities. The totals are also adjusted to reflect cases in which federal and state or local agencies cooperated and issued separate announcements of the outcome. Duplicate or overlapping penalty amounts are marked with an asterisk in the list below.

Links: Subsidy Tracker data on financial assistance to this company by federal, state and local government agencies can be found here.

Individual Penalty Records:

Click on the company or penalty amount for more information on each case.

Company	Primary Offense Type	Year	Agency	Penalty Amount
FirstEnergy Nuclear Operating Company	nuclear safety violation	2000	NRC	$110,000
First Energy/Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company	labor relations violation	2001	NLRB	$27,382,600
ALLEGHENY ENERGY SUPPLY CO LLC	environmental violation	2001	PA-ENV	$25,000
FirstEnergy Corp. and Eslich Wrecking Co.	environmental violation	2001	OH-ENV	$15,000
ALLEGHENY POWER	workplace safety or health violation	2001	OSHA	$20,000
Metropolitan Edison Company and Pennsylvania Electric Company d/b/a Met-Ed/Pennelec	labor relations violation	2002	NLRB	$60,000
ALLEGHENY ENERGY SUPPLY CO LLC	environmental violation	2002	PA-ENV	$10,000
ILLUMINATING CO.; A FIRST ENERGY COMPANY	workplace safety or health violation	2002	OSHA	$70,000
Jersey Central Power and Light Company, A First Energy Company	labor relations violation	2003	NLRB	$495,000
First Energy Corporation	labor relations violation	2003	NLRB	$65,000
ALLEGHENY ENERGY SUPPLY CO LLC	environmental violation	2003	PA-ENV	$6,750
ILLUMINATING CO.; A FIRST ENERGY COMPANY	workplace safety or health violation	2003	OSHA	$8,500
FIRST ENERGY GENERATION CORPORATION	workplace safety or health violation	2004	OSHA	$9,000
ALLEGHENY POWER	workplace safety or health violation	2004	OSHA	$5,250
Ohio Edison Company	environmental violation	2005	EPA	$1,133,500,000
FirstEnergy Nuclear Operating Company	nuclear safety violation	2005	NRC	$5,450,000
Ohio Edison	environmental violation	2005	MULTI-AG	(*)Penalty amounts marked by an asterisk are ones announced by more than one agency. Parent penalty totals are adjusted to avoid double-counting. $18,900,000
ALLEGHENY ENERGY SUPPLY CO LLC	environmental violation	2005	PA-ENV	$27,150
FIRSTENERGY CORP. DBA FIRSTENERGY GENERATION CORP.	workplace safety or health violation	2005	OSHA	$7,000
OHIO EDISON CO, ET. AL.	environmental violation	2005	EPA	(*)Penalty amounts marked by an asterisk are ones announced by more than one agency. Parent penalty totals are adjusted to avoid double-counting. $8,005,000
FirstEnergy Nuclear Operating Company	nuclear safety violation	2006	NRC	$28,000,000
ALLEGHENY ENERGY SUPPLY CO LLC	environmental violation	2006	PA-ENV	$8,100
ALLEGHENY ENERGY SUPPLY CO LLC	environmental violation	2006	PA-ENV	$10,000
ALLEGHENY ENERGY	environmental violation	2006	MD-ENV	$20,000
Allegheny Power	consumer protection violation	2006	PA-PUC	$175,000
FirstEnergy Service Company	labor relations violation	2007	NLRB	$15,000
Allegheny Energy, Inc.	benefit plan administrator violation	2007	private lawsuit-federal	$4,000,000
ALLEGHENY ENERGY SUPPLY CO LLC	environmental violation	2007	PA-ENV	$15,000
ALLEGHENY ENERGY SUPPLY CO LLC	environmental violation	2007	PA-ENV	$9,500
FirstEnergy Generation Corp.	environmental violation	2007	PA-ENV	$25,000
FirstEnergy Generation Corp	environmental violation	2007	PA-ENV	$25,000
JERSEY CENTRAL POWER AND LIGHT	utility safety violation	2007	NJ-BPU	$25,000
FirstEnergy Generation Corp.	labor relations violation	2008	NLRB	$12,160
ALLEGHENY ENERGY SUPPLY LLC	environmental violation	2008	PA-ENV	$23,500
ALLEGHENY ENERGY SUPPLY LLC	environmental violation	2008	PA-ENV	$26,645
ALLEGHENY ENERGY SUPPLY CO LLC	environmental violation	2009	PA-ENV	$59,178
FirstEnergy	consumer protection violation	2009	PA-PUC	$200,000
Metropolitan Edison Company	utility safety violation	2009	PA-PUC	$25,000
Pennsylvania Electric Co.	consumer protection violation	2009	PA-PUC	$200,000
JERSEY CENTRAL POWER & LIGHT COMPANY	workplace safety or health violation	2009	OSHA	$5,000
Metropolitan Edison Company	consumer protection violation	2010	PA-PUC	$100,000
FIRST ENERGY CORP	environmental violation	2010	EPA	$8,500,000
Jersey Central Power & Light	wage and hour violation	2011	WHD	$182,640
ALLEGHENY ENERGY SUPPLY CO LLC	environmental violation	2011	PA-ENV	$22,001
Allegheny Energy	environmental violation	2011	MD-ENV	$30,000
ALLEGHENY ENERGY SUPPLY COMPANY, LLC	workplace safety or health violation	2011	OSHA	$5,950
FIRST ENERGY GENERATION CORPORATION	workplace safety or health violation	2011	OSHA	$12,000
FIRST ENERGY/OHIO EDISON COMPANY	workplace safety or health violation	2011	OSHA	$14,000
FirstEnergy Corp.	wage and hour violation	2012	WHD	$11,999
ALLEGHENY ENERGY SUPPLY CO LLC	environmental violation	2012	PA-ENV	$14,680
Allegheny Energy Company	environmental violation	2012	MD-ENV	$35,000
JERSEY CENTRAL POWER & LIGHT COMPANY	workplace safety or health violation	2012	OSHA	$21,000
ALLEGHENY ENERGY SUPPLY COMPANY, LLC	workplace safety or health violation	2012	OSHA	$5,500
FirstEnergy Corp.	wage and hour violation	2013	WHD	$79,164
FirstEnergy Corp. (Akron, OH)	environmental violation	2013	EPA	$214,604
FirstEnergy Corp. (Akron, OH)	environmental violation	2013	EPA	$166,848
FirstEnergy Corp. (Akron, OH)	environmental violation	2013	EPA	$174,605
FirstEnergy Corp.	wage and hour violation	2014	WHD	$634,742
ALLEGHENY ENERGY	environmental violation	2014	MD-ENV	$65,000
Potomac Edison Company	environmental violation	2014	MD-ENV	$5,000
West Penn Power Company	utility administrative violation	2014	PA-PUC	$1,300,000
West Penn Power Company	utility safety violation	2014	PA-PUC	$86,000
OHIO EDISON COMPANY	workplace safety or health violation	2014	OSHA	$7,000
OHIO EDISON COMPANY	workplace safety or health violation	2015	OSHA	$7,000
Toledo Edison Co.	environmental violation	2016	OH-ENV	$76,318
Jersey Central Power & Light Company	environmental violation	2016	EPA	$50,500
ALLEGHENY ENERGY SUPPLY CO LLC	environmental violation	2017	PA-ENV	$7,500
Potomac Edison Company	consumer protection violation	2017	MD-PSC	$25,000
FIRSTENERGY GENERATION LLC	workplace safety or health violation	2017	OSHA	$65,964
ALLEGHENY ENERGY SUPPLY LLC	environmental violation	2019	PA-ENV	$50,000
ALLEGHENY ENERGY SUPPLY CO LLC	environmental violation	2019	PA-ENV	$30,000
ALLEGHENY ENERGY SUPPLY CO LLC	environmental violation	2019	PA-ENV	$7,916
METROPOLITAN EDISON INC.	workplace safety or health violation	2020	OSHA	$16,386
FirstEnergy Corp.	kickbacks and bribery	2021	USAO	$230,000,000
Metropolitan Edison Company	utility safety violation	2021	PA-PUC	$1,000,000
West Penn Power	environmental violation	2022	EPA	$610,000
West Penn Power Co.	utility safety violation	2022	PA-PUC	$1,175,000
FirstEnergy Corp.	energy market violation	2022	FERC	$3,860,000
FirstEnergy Corp.	consumer protection violation	2022	private lawsuit-federal	$49,000,000
WEST PENN POWER COMPANY	environmental violation	2022	EPA	(*)Penalty amounts marked by an asterisk are ones announced by more than one agency. Parent penalty totals are adjusted to avoid double-counting. $610,000